Who is better: Sidney Crosby or Connor McDavid?

In a head-to-head statistical comparison across 9 career categories, Sidney Crosby leads in more statistical categories. Sidney Crosby wins 5 categories while Connor McDavid wins 1 out of 9 compared. Sidney Crosby's peak Points was 120 (2007), while Connor McDavid peaked at 153 (2023). See the full breakdown on GOAT vs GOAT.

Who is the NHL Hockey GOAT: Sidney or Connor?

The NHL Hockey GOAT debate between Sidney Crosby and Connor McDavid is one of the most passionately debated topics in sports history. Statistically, Sidney Crosby leads in 5 career categories while Connor McDavid leads in 1. Both have legendary careers that defined nhl hockey. Compare their complete career stats, championships, individual awards, and season-by-season performance on GOAT vs GOAT to decide for yourself.

How do Sidney Crosby and Connor McDavid compare statistically?

Across 9 statistical categories, Sidney Crosby leads in 5 and Connor McDavid leads in 1 with 3 tied. GOAT vs GOAT provides detailed breakdowns including career totals, per-season stats, radar charts for skills comparison, and career peak analysis to give you the complete picture of this nhl hockey rivalry.

How many career points does Sidney Crosby have?

Sidney Crosby has 1,594 career points. Compare Sidney Crosby's complete nhl hockey career statistics with Connor McDavid and other legends on GOAT vs GOAT.

What are Connor McDavid's total career points?

Connor McDavid has 899 total career points. See the full season-by-season breakdown and compare with Sidney Crosby on GOAT vs GOAT.

Back to NHL Hockey

Sidney Crosby vs Connor McDavid: Who is the GOAT?

Sidney Crosby

Canada

Connor McDavid

Canada

🏒 NHL Hockey • Career Comparison

The Sidney Crosby vs Connor McDavid GOAT debate is one of the most iconic in nhl hockey history. Compare their complete career stats, championships, individual awards, and head-to-head records side by side. Who leads in more categories? Who had the better peak? Cast your vote and settle the nhl hockey GOAT debate once and for all.

Compare Players

Sidney Crosby

Canada

Connor McDavid

Canada

Head-to-Head Score

Crosby

Ties

McDavid

Out of 9 statistical categories

Why They're GOATs

Why

Crosby is a GOAT

Why

McDavid is a GOAT

Skills Comparison

Career Peak Season

Best Points in a single season

Crosby

120

2006-07

McDavid

153

2022-23

BEST

Detailed Statistics

🏒

Scoring

Crosby

Stat

McDavid

592✓

Goals

335

1,002✓

Assists

564

1,594✓

Points

899

🏆

Awards

Crosby

Stat

McDavid

3✓

Stanley Cups

Hart Trophies

✓4

Points Over Time

Comparing players by career season (Year 1 = rookie season)

Explore More Comparisons

Discover more head-to-head matchups between legendary athletes in this sport.

Browse All Players

The GOAT Verdict

In the Sidney Crosby vs Connor McDavid GOAT debate, the numbers tell a compelling story. Across 9 statistical categories, Sidney Crosby leads in 5 categories while Connor McDavid leads in 1, with 3 tied.

Looking at peak performance in Points, Sidney Crosby reached 120 in 2007, while Connor McDavid hit 153 in 2023.

Ultimately, the nhl hockey GOAT debate between Sidney Crosby and Connor McDavid comes down to what you value most: raw statistics, championships, longevity, or peak dominance. Cast your vote above and see how the community weighs in on this legendary nhl hockey rivalry.

Share this debate

Sidney Crosby vs Connor McDavid - Who's the GOAT?

goatvsgoat.app/sports/nhl/compare/sidney-crosby-vs-connor-mcdavid